NIKOLA TESLA VÀ THOMAS EDISON

In 2013, plans were underway to build the Tesla Science Center in Shoređam mê, Thủ đô New York, where the genius inventor Nikola Tesla"s laboratory once operated. But there was a problem. The site had fallen into disrepair since Tesla worked there, & it was overrun by thiông chồng, tall weeds. That didn"t stop Tesla"s fans. They brought their own tools, including those machetes, & spent their weekends hacking away the brush.

Bạn đang xem: Nikola tesla và thomas edison

Today Tesla is a geek inhỏ, credited with pioneering alternating current and radio. He inspires tributes around the world (and occasionally long gardening sessions). That geeky cult is part of the reason the new Tesla Center is being built. Matthew Inman, author of a famous comic strip at the Oatmeal about how Tesla is awesome, kicked off a $1.37 million crowdfunding chiến dịch to lớn help build the new museum.

But that enthusiasm has come at a cost — slamming Thomas Edison at every opportunity. In the popular imagination, Tesla & Edison were mortal enemies, và everybody has to pick a side. Inman"s famous comic argues that Tesla, not Edison, was "the greademo geek who ever lived," while Edison "was a idiot" who stole ideas and merely profited off patents.

But the Tesla-Edison rivalry reaches far beyond a webcomic that"s a few years old. It"s gone from viral image lớn ever-present meme to lớn pop culture canon. Rather than fizzling in the past couple of years, the feud"s hype has only grown. It"s shown up on T-shirts, in movie speculation, và even in parody rap battles:

That the rivalry has boomed is all new và a bit surreal. For most of the 20th century, Edison was America"s greademo inventor và a nhân vật of the industrial age, valorized for his hard work and ingenuity. But lately, it"s Tesla who"s seen his stature rise as a hero of the big idea và the true symbol of Silicon Valley–style innovation. The two are portrayed as representing completely different ideas of scientific progress, with a rivalry fit for a summer movie.

But is that blockbuster battle really accurate? A closer look at the historical feud between Tesla và Edison suggests that how we think of them today says less about the two inventors than it does about ourselves.

The real story behind the famous Tesla-Edison feud


*
*

In 1884, a 28-year-old Serbian named Nikola Tesla arrived in New York City & quickly found a job with Thomas Edison, who, at 37, had already invented a new type of telegraph, created a pioneering lab, and founded the Edison Illuminating Company that developed Edison"s work in electrical light. In his new position, Tesla helped Edison install lab equipment, repair generators, and thiết kế new machines.

A year later, Tesla left to start his own electric lighting company. The new system he used relied on alternating currents for induction motors — which mix the stage for his famous conflict with Edison.

The dispute centered on which type of electric current should become the universal standard in the United States. Edison preferred direct current (DC), which was already widely used (and which Edison was profiting off of through his patents). But DC had a key drawback: It was difficult khổng lồ convert the low voltage from power plants inlớn high-voltage transmission lines that could carry electriđô thị long distances. So a DC system would require many smaller power plants built cthua lớn users.

Tesla"s alternating current (AC) system fixed this problem. Using transformers, the voltages could be raised & lowered, making it possible to have power plants many miles from wherever power was being used. Tesla sold his patents khổng lồ George Westinghouse, who promoted the new AC system against Edison"s.

The resulting "current wars" did turn inlớn a genuine rivalry — at least for a while. Edison launched a publicity campaign to promote DC, which included public displays of AC electrocution in front of a live sầu audience. In 1903, Edison supervised workers as they electrocuted an elephant named Topsy. (The lô ghích wasn"t particularly sound: It was like saying drowning cats in vats of soda proves that sugar is bad for you.)

But the spat also ended pretty quickly — & Edison lost. As early as 1893, Westinghouse had won a bid lớn electrify the World"s Fair. By 1896, General Electric had ditched DC for AC, which eventually became the dominant system in the United States. And Tesla, for his part, moved on to lớn new inventions quickly —by 1892, he was already lecturing in London about his plans for radio. Edison"s elephant electrocution was an after-the-fact flail at relevance — DC had already lost.

Historians say this feud was a blip, not an epic conflict. And it just wasn"t as bitter as today"s mythmakers suggest. "Tesla just didn"t worry about Edison," says W. Bernard Carlson, who wrote about Tesla in Tesla: Inventor of the Electrical Age. "He actually kind of idolized him when he worked for hyên. He was annoyed, but there wasn"t this lifelong bitter animosity that you see being conjured up." (If Tesla fans are looking for a true rival, every biographer I talked to lớn suggested Guglielmo Marconi, who built off Tesla"s work lớn "invent" radio. Their rivalry actually had the vitriol we imagine in the Tesla-Edison dispute.)

The "current wars" were a fascinating but short-lived business dispute. The tougher question is how this spat got transformed, in our historical memory, into a battle more fit for a Marvel movie than a business textbook.

Tesla and Edison weren"t as different as we like khổng lồ believe

*

Tesla"s biggest fans champion him as an isolated aesthete, focused on creating breakthrough inventions lượt thích his ideas for wireless electriđô thị. They also portray Thomas Edison as a cutthroat businessman who wasn"t nearly as inventive sầu as Tesla — but was simply better at patenting ideas, relying on truly inventive sầu assistants, and bamboozling the easily impressed media.

The truth is somewhere in between. Tesla was also a businessman who was aware of the importance of the press. To create his great ideas, he needed the money và support to vì it. And he often exaggerated his claims. "He had a complicated relationship with the tabloids of the time," Carlson says. Tesla"s pitches didn"t always pan out — but he still made them with vigor.

Edison, meanwhile, certainly wasn"t viewed as a haông xã by most of his contemporaries — he was hailed a genius, for both technical & business acumen. That was true for the period spanning from Edison"s invention of the lightbulb in 1879 to his death in 1931. "He was the inventor with the golden touch, who was lượt thích a living god," says Randall Stross, who wrote the Edison biography The Wizard of Menlo Park.

Xem thêm: Những Bài Hát Hit Mới Của Sơn Tùng, Erik Thắng Cuộc Với Điểm Số Cách Biệt

It"s true that Edison purchased intellectual property & had a team working for him, but he was also a genius with many accomplishments to his name. Fueled by his workaholic habits (he labored until midnight the night of his wedding), Edison created a device that allowed two messages to be sent in both directions at the same time — a major innovation early on in the telegraph, and something that required a geek"s talent and obsession. His innovations ranged from quirky experiments lượt thích his battery-powered pen to lớn iconic inventions lượt thích the phonograph. And these early strokes of genius can"t be entirely attributed khổng lồ smart assistants or opportunistic patenting. At the very least, even Edison"s critics have to admit he"s like the best aspects of Bill Gates & Steve sầu Jobs rolled into lớn one.

Modern-day Tesla fans lượt thích to lớn argue that Edison simply worked the truyền thông media better, and that explains his fame. It"s true that Edison knew how lớn tease the press. Journalists recorded every remark he made, newspapers breathlessly reported on the tests he used for potential hires (the same way they vì chưng for Google today), & thousands made the pilgrimage khổng lồ Edison"s home base in Menlo Park, New Jersey. " was regarded as the preeminent authority on just about anything," says Stross. "I can"t think any person today would be regarded in the same way — as an omniscient sage."

But Tesla wasn"t a shy shadow of Edison, either — he was a competitor for truyền thông attention. They had different pitches to the truyền thông media, but both men had hooks to offer. "With Edison," Carlson says, "it"s about Yankee ingenuity. With Tesla, because of his absence of commercial results, he takes a more utopian vision ... he"s sort of the more long-term social vision of what technology can vì."

The modern myth about the two inventors is unrealistic. Tesla wasn"t an angelic martyr for science, and Edison wasn"t a craven businessman who stole all of his ideas. Each of them was a little bit of both, not a total nhân vật or villain.

How we think about them is a reflection of modern values — our beliefs run through them, like current through power lines.

What Tesla"s modern-day comebaông chồng — và Edison"s fall — says about us

*

Jane Alcorn didn"t always know who Nikola Tesla was. She was introduced khổng lồ hyên ổn in the mid-1990s by a neighbor with a "TESLA" license plate. After learning a bit about the inventor, Alcorn was hooked. "His life is a very compelling story," she tells me.


What people call Nikola Tesla

Tesla was a saint, a hacker nhân vật, a feminist, and, of course, a target of the Illuminati.


Alcorn soon led the fight lớn restore Tesla"s long-lost lab in Shoreham, Thủ đô New York. At first, it was an uphill battle: In the 1990s, few people knew who Tesla was, even in the nearby area. He was a forgotten inventor.

Now that"s changed. Everyone loves Tesla. The community around Shoremê man even has signs with pictures of Tesla"s Wardenclyffe Tower, the early wireless transmission tower at the lab.

Biographers have different theories about why Tesla has enjoyed a modern-day revival — and why Edison"s become a relic.

Jill Jonnes, author of Empires of Light: Edison, Tesla, Westinghouse, and the Race to lớn Electrify the World, thinks that it"s become harder lớn appreciate Edison"s contributions because we take them for granted. Today we"re so used khổng lồ available electric light that it"s tough to appreciate the breakthrough. But that wasn"t true in the 19th and early 20th century: "People loved Edison & worshipped hlặng, because in their own lifetimes they"d seen their lives change because of this one man," Jonnes says.

Meanwhile, most of Nikola Tesla"s ideas and visions, barely realized while he was alive, seem more exciting today. We can still get excited about wireless electrithành phố and new forms of communication. It"s no coincidence that the hottest electric oto company is named after Tesla — Tesla"s name evokes the future, while Edison"s is covered in dust.

Carlson, the Tesla biographer, argues that the inventor might be a more appropriate anh hùng for Silinhỏ Valley"s genius-worshiping culture, where breakthroughs that can change the world are prized over incremental innovations that make the world slightly better. "The central myth of Silicon Valley is that silinhỏ has changed the world," he says. "Tesla, in their mind, is one of those visionaries that said bold changes are going lớn undergird the future of society. Edison was just building companies."


What people điện thoại tư vấn Thomas Edison

Edison was a total jerk, a pompous idiot, a patent troll, and, of course, a member of the Illuminati.


Stross, the Edison biographer, argues that might explain why Edison isn"t likely lớn make a comebaông chồng anytime soon. "In choosing historical figures that we"re going to lớn embrace," he says, "we"re going khổng lồ choose one whose defining feature is brilliance. I see Edison as a creature of the past who isn"t going lớn come bachồng in any khung."

Tesla himself, at least in one quotation, helped sculpt the myth into lớn the size it"s taken today. The day after Edison died, Tesla perfectly articulated what would become each man"s public image. "Edison was by far the most successful and, probably, the last exponent of this purely empirical method of investigation," he told the Thủ đô New York Times in 1931. "A little theory và calculation would have sầu saved him 90% of the labor."

The most famous bromide we associate with Edison, about how genius is 10 percent inspiration & 90 percent perspiration, doesn"t fit with the culture at large today. We prefer to lớn have sầu our epiphanies in air-conditioned rooms. We don"t lượt thích to sweat.

Is there a better way to think about the Tesla-Edison rivalry?

*

After Tesla died, his laboratory at Wardenclyffe was used as a photo lớn processing facility. It later became a Superfund site & required significant environmental cleanup. But Jane Alcorn và her team are committed to lớn restoring it. There are plans for a museum devoted lớn Tesla"s work, his laboratory, & his inventions. There will be interactive displays & a theater for presentations, & students will eat in the Neon Cafe (because Tesla pioneered some of the first neon lights).

Yet even Alcorn, whose project has benefited so much from Tesla cheerleading, was reluctant to angrily condemn Edison lượt thích so many Tesla fans on the mạng internet. She loves Tesla, & she thinks the rivalry definitely existed. But she also says that "in their later years, they had a begrudging respect."

It might be more accurate to honor Tesla và Edison by recognizing the complexity of their conflict, as well as the virtues & shortcomings each possessed. Both men were geniuses, in their own ways, & both men were fallible, too. Instead of fitting Tesla to our own age or judging Edison selectively, we could try lớn understvà both men better on their own terms. (Even Inman, the author of the Oatmeal comic, long ago conceded that his view of the Tesla-Edison feud was a bit exaggerated, though he hasn"t backed off entirely.)

But moderation could be another step in the wrong direction, too — both men never gave sầu up their passion. And without an exaggerated view of Tesla và Edison, the Wardenclyffe lab, overrun by vines & in desperate need of cleanup, might never have been restored.

Sometimes it takes a good myth to get people khổng lồ bring out their machetes.


We have sầu a request

In moments like this — as people grtáo bị cắn dở lớn underst& variants & vaccines, & kids head baông xã khổng lồ school — many outlets take their paywalls down. 8004.info’s nội dung is always không lấy phí, in part because of financial tư vấn from our readers. We’ve sầu been covering the Covid-19 pandemic for more than a year & a half. From the beginning, our goal was khổng lồ bring clarity to lớn chaos. To empower people with the information they needed khổng lồ stay safe. And we’re not stopping. In the next 30 days, we’re aiming to lớn add 2,500 individual contributions to help keep our coverage of the Covid-19 crisis không lấy phí for everyone who needs it. As each of us is only as healthy as our sickest neighbor, it’s essential that people can access clear information on the pandemic for miễn phí. Will you help us reach our goal by making a contribution to 8004.info with as little as $3?